Liverpool legend and Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has sparked debate by suggesting that Mohamed Salah should not be an automatic starter for the
Liverpool legend and Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has sparked debate by suggesting that Mohamed Salah should not be an automatic starter for the Reds anymore.
Speaking on The Gary Neville Podcast, Carragher pointed to Salah’s recent struggles, including a seven-game Premier League drought without a goal from open play — the longest since he joined the club in 2017.
The comments followed Liverpool’s 2-1 defeat to Manchester United, where Salah missed two clear chances and looked off the pace throughout the match.
Carragher argued that Liverpool manager Arne Slot must now make tough decisions regarding Salah’s role, especially as the team adapts to a new tactical approach.
“I think we’re at that stage now where Mo Salah shouldn’t be a guaranteed starter every week,” Carragher said.
He emphasized that Salah, now 33, should not be treated like Virgil van Dijk—someone who is always the first name on the team sheet.
Instead, Carragher advised Slot to consider rotating Salah, particularly in away games where his impact has waned.
The former defender also highlighted the importance of managing veteran players carefully to maintain squad balance and performance levels.
Liverpool is enduring a rough patch where they have lost four consecutive matches and are slipping in the league standings. They now sit third behind Manchester City and Arsenal in second and first place, respectively.
Carragher believes that relying too heavily on ageing stars could hinder progress.
He noted that Salah’s new two-year contract should not guarantee him a starting role, especially when younger players are pushing for opportunities.
Carragher’s comments have ignited discussion among fans and pundits, with some agreeing that Salah’s form warrants a rethink, while others argue his experience and goal-scoring record still make him indispensable.
As Liverpool navigates a transitional phase under Slot, the handling of Salah’s role could prove pivotal in shaping the team’s future.
Whether the Egyptian forward accepts a reduced role or fights to reclaim his status remains to be seen, but Carragher’s remarks have certainly added pressure to the conversation.
COMMENTS